Whether you’re a local, a weekend visitor, or someone considering a move to Monmouth County, one thing’s for sure — we take our baked goods seriously. From warm artisan loaves to Instagram-worthy cupcakes, this area is filled with bakeries that will make you feel right at home (and maybe tempt you into a daily croissant habit). 🍰
Here’s our roundup of some of the best bakeries in Monmouth County that are worth the drive — or better yet, worth living nearby!
1. Balthazar Bakery – Englishtown
A hidden gem for serious bread lovers. Known for their rustic French loaves and perfectly flaky pastries, Balthazar is a wholesale bakery with a retail outlet that feels like a slice of Paris in NJ.
📍 16 Commerce Dr, Englishtown
2. Nothing Bundt Cakes – Shrewsbury
Sometimes you just need cake — and this chain delivers perfection every time. Their signature bundt cakes come in all sizes and flavors, and make the best last-minute gift (or self-treat).
📍 1021 Broad St, Shrewsbury
3. Antoinette Boulangerie – Red Bank
This French-style bakery is beloved for its almond croissants, baguettes, and seasonal tarts. Step inside and you’ll swear you’re in a quaint Parisian café.
📍 32 Monmouth St, Red Bank
4. Cravings Desserts – Allenhurst
A boutique bakery creating show-stopping cakes and gourmet desserts. Great for weddings, celebrations, or just impressing your guests with something from a local favorite.
📍 311 Main St, Allenhurst
5. Mueller’s Bakery – Bay Head
A Jersey Shore classic since 1890! Known for crumb cake, jelly donuts, and warm hospitality, Mueller’s is a must-stop after a day at the beach.
📍 80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head (technically Ocean County, but worth the extra 5-minute drive!)
6. Luigi’s Famous Pizza & Bakery – Red Bank
Don’t be fooled by the name — while Luigi’s is known for their pizza, their bakery side offers incredible Italian pastries, cannoli, and cookies just like Nonna used to make.
📍 75 Broad St, Red Bank
7. The Scone Pony – Spring Lake
As cute as its name, this charming bakery specializes in buttery scones, pies, and specialty treats that are perfect for a morning by the shore or a weekend brunch.
📍 305 Washington Ave, Spring Lake
Why do local bakeries matter in real estate?
They’re part of what makes a neighborhood feel like home. Great bakeries mean walkable charm, community, and of course—delicious mornings. 🥐